Constitutional Court

Constitutional Court, Ecuador, ICSID Arbitration, Latin America, Trade and investment agreements, Uncategorized

, , , (Tadir Dispute Resolution)/ /Leave a comment

Ecuador distanced itself from the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (“ICSID”) system more than a decade ago. During this period, Ecuador withdrew from all its bilateral investment treaties (“BITs”) and the 1966 Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes between States and Nationals of Other States (“ICSID Convention” or “Convention”). In August 2021,…

Constitutional Court, Constitutional proceeding, Ecuador, ICSID, ICSID Arbitration

(MIDS - Geneva Center for International Dispute Settlement)/ /Leave a comment

In a new chapter of Ecuador’s backlash to the Investor-State Dispute Settlement (ISDS) system saga, the Constitutional Court of Ecuador (Court) declared Art. 15.20 of the Ecuador-Costa Rica FTA (FTA, Treaty) unconstitutional. This provision provides for ICSID or UNCITRAL arbitration in case of violation of the substantive protections accorded to foreign investors in the Treaty…

Annulment, Arab World, Constitutional Court, Egypt, MENA

(Amereller)/ /1 Comment

On 6 January 2021, the Egyptian Government introduced a draft law for parliament’s approval, seeking to expand the Egyptian Supreme Constitutional Court’s (“ESCC”) jurisdiction to scrutinize international arbitration awards rendered against the Egyptian State and acts of international organizations affecting the Egyptian State. The legislative amendment is in line with previous legislative measures designed to…

Constitutional Court, Ecuador, ICSID Convention, Investment protection, Ratification

(Tobar ZVS)/ /Leave a comment

On 15 January 1986, Ecuador signed the Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes between States and Nationals of other States (“ICSID Convention”). During President Rafael Correa´s administration (2007-2017), President Correa publicly expressed his hostility towards the ICSID Convention and the international investment protection system. In 2008, Ecuador denounced over a third of its bilateral…

Annulment, Constitutional Court, Ecuador, Latin America, Revision of Award

(Tobar ZVS)/ /Leave a comment

I .The Annulment of an Arbitral Award under Ecuadorian Law Pursuant to article 30 of the Arbitration and Mediation Law (AML), arbitral awards are final and binding for the parties. In other words, parties cannot file recourses to challenge an award, with the exception of a clarification or extension petition before the arbitral tribunal. However,…

2019 In Review, Chile, Colombia, Constitutional Court, Damages, Dominican Republic, Dual Nationals, Ecuador, Free Trade Agreements, Investment Arbitration, Latin America, Mexico, USMCA

(Locke Lord LLP)/ /Leave a comment

Introduction In 2019, we witnessed a number of interesting developments in the field of investment arbitration in Latin America. While some of them were in line with expectations, some jurisdictions did deviate from their usual or expected approach to ISDS and surprised us in positive, but also in negative ways. Our authors did a tremendous…

2019 In Review, Amparo, Arbitration Act, arbitrators’ conduct, Brazil, Bribery, Colombia, Commercial Arbitration, Constitutional Court, Costa Rica, Ecuador, Guaidó, Kluwer Arbitration Blog, Latin America, Mexico, OAS Guide, Odebrecht investigation, Paraguay, Peru, Venezuela

(Herbert Smith Freehills)/ /Leave a comment

2019 was a lively year for international arbitration in Latin America – especially in the international commercial arbitration arena, which is the focus of this post. Contributors to Kluwer Arbitration Blog reported mostly on favorable developments on arbitration-related legislation, case law and other initiatives. The year, however, ended with a regrettable situation in Peru, where…

Amparo, Colombia, Constitutional Court, International arbitration, International Public Policy, Tutela

(Talero Rueda & Asociados)/ /Leave a comment

In its recent decision T-354/2019, the Colombian Constitutional Court, through one of its chambers, declared that arbitration awards, issued in international arbitrations seated in Colombia, may be subject to constitutional challenges by means of the so-called acción de tutela.1)The acción de tutela is similar to the so-called recurso de amparo, a constitutional injunction widely known…

Awards, Colombia, Constitutional Court, International arbitration, Tutela

, (Zuleta Abogados)/ /1 Comment

On August 6, 2019, the Fifth Revision Chamber of Colombia’s Constitutional Court (the “Court”) issued judgment T-354/19 resolving a constitutional injunction (tutela)1)The tutela is a constitutional injunction that aims to protect fundamental constitutional rights when they are violated or threatened by the action or omission of any public authority. This mechanism is incorporated in Article…